The race to bring Bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs) to mainstream investors has taken dramatically different paths in North America. While Canada swiftly approved multiple Bitcoin ETFs within months—making them accessible to retail and institutional investors alike—the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has continued to delay approval, citing regulatory concerns. This contrast raises a critical question: Why has Canada moved so fast, while the U.S. remains cautious?
To understand this divergence, we need to examine the regulatory environments, market dynamics, and investor demand shaping each country’s approach to cryptocurrency innovation.
The Rise of Bitcoin ETFs in Canada
In early 2021, Canada made history by launching the world’s first Bitcoin ETF. On February 18, 2021, Purpose Investments Inc. debuted the Purpose Bitcoin ETF (BTCC) on the Toronto Stock Exchange. It became an instant success, recording $145 million in trading volume on its first day with 9.3 million shares traded—making it one of the most active securities on the exchange that day.
Just weeks later, Evolve Funds Group Inc. received approval for its Bitcoin ETF, trading under EBIT (CAD) and EBIT.U (USD). By March 5, CI Galaxy Bitcoin ETF (BTCX) joined the market, co-launched by Galaxy Digital and CI Financial Corp. These rapid approvals signaled a bold regulatory stance from Canadian authorities, particularly the Ontario Securities Commission (OSC), which prioritized investor access and financial innovation.
👉 Discover how global markets are shaping the future of digital asset investing.
Canada wasn't alone in embracing this trend. Brazil followed shortly after, approving its first Bitcoin ETF (QBTC11) on March 19, becoming the second country to do so. Dubai also entered the space in April, listing a Bitcoin ETF from Canadian firm 3iQ on Nasdaq Dubai. These international moves highlighted growing global confidence in regulated crypto investment vehicles.
What Is a Bitcoin ETF?
An exchange-traded fund (ETF) is an investment vehicle that tracks the performance of an underlying asset or index. Unlike direct ownership, investors buy shares in the fund rather than holding the actual asset.
A Bitcoin ETF allows investors to gain exposure to Bitcoin price movements without managing private keys, wallets, or exchanges. This simplifies entry for traditional investors who may be unfamiliar with blockchain technology but want to diversify into digital assets.
Key advantages include:
- Lower barrier to entry: No need to navigate crypto exchanges or cold storage.
- Regulated structure: Listed on traditional stock exchanges with oversight.
- Liquidity and transparency: Traded like stocks with real-time pricing and reporting.
For institutions and financial advisors, ETFs offer a compliant way to integrate Bitcoin into portfolios—without operational complexity.
Strong Institutional Demand Drives ETF Applications
Despite regulatory delays, demand for Bitcoin ETFs remains strong—especially among institutional investors.
A 2021 survey by Goldman Sachs revealed that over one-third of institutional clients already held digital assets, and more than half planned to expand their crypto allocations in the coming months. This surge in interest reflects a broader shift: cryptocurrencies are increasingly seen as a legitimate asset class.
Matt Hougan, Chief Investment Officer at Bitwise Asset Management, noted that ETFs could significantly broaden access:
“Beyond opening doors for retail investors, a Bitcoin ETF makes it easier for financial advisors to recommend crypto exposure to their clients.”
With over $1 billion in crypto assets under management, Bitwise has been actively pursuing ETF approval in the U.S., underscoring the commercial incentive behind these filings.
Ark Invest, led by Cathie Wood—often dubbed the “Queen of Tech Stocks”—filed for its ARK 21Shares Bitcoin ETF (ARKB) in June 2021. The fund aims to track the S&P Bitcoin Index, offering transparent exposure rooted in rigorous research. Ark’s previous success—delivering a 143% return in 2020—gave its application significant market visibility.
Why Hasn’t the U.S. SEC Approved a Bitcoin ETF?
While investor demand grows, the SEC has maintained a cautious stance. The primary concern? Market manipulation and price integrity.
SEC officials worry that Bitcoin’s decentralized and relatively unregulated markets are vulnerable to manipulation—especially given high-profile incidents involving major players like Elon Musk.
For example:
- In February 2021, Tesla announced a $1.5 billion Bitcoin purchase, causing Bitcoin’s price to jump nearly 18% in a single day.
- In May, Musk tweeted that Tesla would suspend Bitcoin payments due to environmental concerns—triggering a 7% drop.
- Days later, speculation that Tesla had sold its holdings caused Bitcoin to plunge over 10%, only to rebound when Musk clarified otherwise.
These events illustrate how social media sentiment from influential figures can sway markets—a red flag for regulators focused on investor protection.
Gary Gensler, who became SEC Chair in 2021 and previously taught blockchain at MIT, has expressed openness to crypto innovation—but only within strict regulatory guardrails. His appointment sparked renewed optimism that a U.S.-listed Bitcoin ETF could eventually be approved, though likely tied to stronger market surveillance and custodial standards.
Could a U.S. Bitcoin ETF Trigger a New Bull Run?
Many analysts believe yes.
Bitcoin is often called “digital gold,” and historical parallels support this analogy. After the U.S. approved its first gold-backed ETF in November 2004, gold prices rose 318% over the next seven years. Factors like increased liquidity, lower transaction costs, and arbitrage opportunities helped drive adoption and valuation.
A similar effect could occur with Bitcoin:
- Lower investment barriers mean more people can participate.
- Higher liquidity attracts institutional capital.
- Mainstream legitimacy boosts public confidence.
With U.S. financial markets representing nearly 56% of global market value (per Statista), approval of a Bitcoin ETF could unlock massive inflows into the crypto ecosystem.
👉 See how early movers are positioning themselves ahead of potential market shifts.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: What is the main difference between buying Bitcoin directly and investing in a Bitcoin ETF?
A: Buying Bitcoin requires using a crypto exchange and managing private keys or wallets. A Bitcoin ETF lets you invest through traditional brokerage accounts without handling the asset directly.
Q: Has any Bitcoin ETF been approved in the U.S.?
A: As of now, no spot Bitcoin ETF has been fully approved by the SEC. However, several applications are under review, including those from major firms like BlackRock and Ark Invest.
Q: Why do regulators care about market manipulation?
A: If prices can be artificially influenced, retail investors may suffer losses based on false signals. Regulators aim to ensure fair and transparent markets.
Q: Are Canadian Bitcoin ETFs available to U.S. investors?
A: Some U.S.-based brokers allow access to Canadian-listed crypto ETFs, but investors should consult tax and compliance rules before investing internationally.
Q: Does a Bitcoin ETF hold actual Bitcoin?
A: Yes—most physically backed Bitcoin ETFs hold real BTC in secure custody solutions to ensure accurate price tracking.
Q: What would change if the SEC finally approves a spot Bitcoin ETF?
A: Approval would likely lead to greater institutional adoption, improved market stability, and potentially higher long-term prices due to sustained capital inflows.
The contrast between Canada’s proactive embrace of Bitcoin ETFs and the U.S.’s measured caution reflects differing regulatory philosophies—not a lack of demand. As global interest grows and markets mature, pressure will continue mounting on the SEC to act.
👉 Stay ahead of regulatory developments and investment opportunities in digital assets.